Order of the Sinking Star, the third game directed by Jonathan Blow, is out on PS5, Nintendo Switch 2 and Windows PC.
Blow says it holds more than 1,400 puzzles and can take up to 250 hours at a normal pace.
It sells for $29.99 on the PlayStation Store and has drawn strong reviews from critics.
Puzzles come from four classic block-pushing game ideas, which later combine into far harder challenges.
Quick read · 1 min
Order of the Sinking Star, the third game directed by Braid and The Witness creator Jonathan Blow, is out on PS5 for $29.99. It also launched on Nintendo Switch 2 and Windows PC, so it isn't a PlayStation exclusive.
It's a grid-based puzzle game in the style of Sokoban. You explore a big map split into four regions, each built on one idea taken from indie puzzle games: a crew of movers with different powers, mirrors, skipping stones and gem-powered beams. Later, the game mixes those rules into tougher combined puzzles.
More than 1,400 puzzles, according to Blow
Up to 250 hours for a normal run, 500-plus to solve everything
Undo and restart buttons make experimenting painless
Critics like it, but it's hard. If you enjoy slow, satisfying brain teasers, it could be the best value on your shelf this year.
Jonathan Blow’s new puzzle game doesn’t ask for a weekend. It asks for a season. Order of the Sinking Star is now on PlayStation 5, and its director says finishing every one of its more than 1,400 puzzles can take over 500 hours.
That matters if you’re deciding where your next $29.99 goes. This is the third game from the designer of Braid and The Witness, two of the most talked-about puzzle games ever made, and it isn’t a PS5 exclusive. It also launched on Nintendo Switch 2 and Windows PC in October, so you can pick the platform that suits how you like to play.
01
What Order of the Sinking Star is on PS5
Order of the Sinking Star is a top-down puzzle adventure built on a grid, in the tradition of Sokoban, the old warehouse game where you push crates onto target squares. You play Queen Effia, who wanders a strange overworld map. Most spots on that map open a single puzzle screen, and solving it unlocks paths further out.
The map is split into four regions, and each one is built around one core idea:
The Hearty Heroes of Hauling: you steer a small crew of movers with different powers. One can push, one can pull, and one can swap places with anything in his line of sight.
The Mirror Isles: mirrors let you hop gaps between islands or make clones of yourself.
Skipping Stones to Lonely Homes: you send stones across water to bridge gaps and reach a goal.
Vault of the Beamcasters: you collect gems that switch on beams, and each beam gives you a new ability.
You can tackle the four regions in any order. The game nudges you toward the Heroes of Hauling first, but reviewers who ignored that advice found it worked fine.
Early trailers promised over 1,000 puzzles, which is the figure PlayStation’s own description still uses. Blow has since said the finished game has more than 1,400. Either way, it’s enormous.
The real twist comes later. Once you’ve cleared enough puzzles across the four regions, the game starts mixing their rules together. A Heroes of Hauling puzzle might suddenly involve mirrored clones of your crew, for example. Blow has also hinted at a third layer of puzzles that he kept secret before launch, and later stages move from flat 2D boards into 3D.
Edge magazine compared the size of the map to Elden Ring, and Blow admitted he came to think of his game as the “Elden Ring of puzzle games”. He also called the job of fusing all these mechanics a “game design supercollider”.
03
Where the ideas came from
Unusually for a big release, the four regions are based on smaller indie browser games by other designers. Alan Hazelden made the originals behind the Mirror Isles and the skipping stones area, Sean Barrett made Promesst, which inspired the Beamcasters vault, and Jonah Ostroff made Heroes of Sokoban. All three helped design levels for the new game, alongside the makers of Patrick’s Parabox, Enigmash and Miegakure.
Blow has said part of the point was to give those games the recognition and polish they never got as web toys. The project began as a test of Jai, a programming language Blow’s studio, Thekla, built in-house because he had grown tired of C++. Development took nearly 10 years, well past the seven The Witness needed, and Arc Games stepped in as publisher when the studio’s money was running low.
The road to launch had some friction. In December 2025, Hazelden publicly praised the game while saying he disagreed with Blow’s views on diversity and inclusion, and Ostroff and Barrett echoed him. Blow didn’t respond publicly and stayed focused on finishing the game.
04
How hard it is, and whether you’ll enjoy it
Expect to get stuck. One reviewer described staring at a single screen for at least 45 minutes, and another spent hours on one optional relic in the opening skipping stones puzzle. The challenge isn’t reflexes. It’s spotting the right sequence of moves when the goal is obvious but the route isn’t.
The game softens that in two ways. You can undo moves one at a time or restart a level instantly, so experimenting costs nothing. And you can walk away from a puzzle and try a different region, which keeps you from hitting a hard wall. You also don’t need to solve everything to see the story through. Blow puts a normal playthrough at up to 250 hours, with the full 500-plus reserved for completionists.
Critics have been warm. Reviews praise the clear visuals, the little character moments between your movers and the steady drip of new ideas. The main complaint from the Switch 2 version was shaky frame rates, which didn’t affect play.
For most PlayStation owners, the question is value and time. At $29.99, this is cheaper than most new games and could last longer than almost anything else in your library. It suits people who enjoy crosswords, chess problems or games like Portal and The Witness, and who are happy to sit with a problem.
If you want action, a strong story up front or quick wins, it may frustrate you. A sensible test: if the opening Heroes of Hauling puzzles grab you in your first hour, you’ll probably love the rest. If they feel like homework, this one isn’t for you.
PC players had a free demo during Steam Next Fest in June, and PS5 players have the launch trailer to judge the style. A boxed edition for PS5 and Switch 2 is planned for later, if you prefer a disc.
06
Quick answers
Is Order of the Sinking Star a PS5 exclusive?
No. It launched on PS5, Nintendo Switch 2 and Windows PC at the same time in October.
How many puzzles are in Order of the Sinking Star?
Early marketing said over 1,000, but Jonathan Blow says the final game has more than 1,400 puzzles.
How long does it take to beat?
Blow estimates up to 250 hours at a normal pace to reach the end, and more than 500 hours to solve every puzzle.
Granblue Fantasy: Relink, Somerville and Fade to Silence exit the Extra and Premium catalog on December 15. Here is what each one is and what replaces them.
Fan-made builds run Nintendo's new Zelda remake on Windows at up to 240 FPS. Here's what they are, how Nintendo is pushing back and where players stand.
6 min read
We use cookies to understand how readers use Talk With Tech, so we can make it better. Is that OK? Privacy policy
The Daily Brief
Today's biggest tech stories, in 5 minutes
Every morning, the news that matters from AI, phones, apps and the people shaping tech. Explained in plain English. Free.
One email a day. No spam, unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy