Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Small $76 verdict spotlights AI plate reader policing risks

A federal jury found Bexar County liable for a stop triggered by license plate reader data. The award is tiny on purpose; the next court order may not be.

Officer vehicle pulled over a car at night in an urban setting

The short version

  • A federal jury awarded Houston driver Alek Schott $76, one dollar for each minute deputies held him in March 2022.
  • The jury found Bexar County, Texas, liable for violating his Fourth Amendment rights, not just one deputy.
  • The stop began with a WhatsApp tip based on license plate reader data that flagged his quick work trip as suspicious.
  • His lawyers plan to ask a judge to bar similar stops; the county has said it may appeal.
Quick read · 1 min

A federal jury in San Antonio awarded Houston driver Alek Schott $76, one dollar for each minute Bexar County deputies held him during a March 2022 stop. The stop started with a WhatsApp tip based on license plate reader data that flagged his one-night work trip to South Texas as suspicious.

The deputy claimed Schott drifted over the fog line, but Schott's dashcam showed he stayed in his lane. A dog search of his truck found nothing.

  • The jury found the county liable at a policy level, not just one deputy.
  • It did not rule plate readers themselves unconstitutional.
  • Every county patrol car now has a plate reader, up from four in 2022.

Schott's lawyers will ask a federal judge to bar similar stops, and the county may appeal.

Alek Schott asked a jury for $76, and he got it. That was one dollar for every minute Bexar County deputies kept him on the side of Interstate 35 in Texas after license plate reader data marked his ordinary work trip as suspicious.

The award is symbolic, but the finding behind it is not. A federal jury in San Antonio found the county liable for violating Schott’s Fourth Amendment rights, which protect against unreasonable searches and seizures. If your car passes license plate cameras on the way to work, this case is a first look at what happens when software decides your route looks odd and police act on it.

01

How a license plate reader flagged a routine work trip

License plate readers are cameras that photograph every passing plate and log where and when each car was seen. Linked together, those sightings form a travel history. Newer systems go further and flag cars based on patterns, such as how far they went and how quickly they came back.

That is what happened here. Schott, a Houston-area salesman who sells supplies to oil and gas pipeline operators, drove to Carrizo Springs in South Texas for work in March 2022. He stayed one night and headed home the next day. To the people watching the data, that quick round trip toward the border region looked like possible smuggling.

The tip reached Deputy Joel Babb through a law enforcement WhatsApp group. In a deposition, Babb said it came from someone called “Kiki” who was said to work with a federal fusion center in Laredo and had near real-time access to plate reader data. Reports disagree on which camera company’s system was involved, so that detail remains unconfirmed.

Close-up of a license plate reader device mounted on a street pole
02

Inside the 76-minute stop

Babb waited for Schott’s pickup and pulled him over on March 16, 2022, saying he had been drifting over the fog line. Schott’s own dashcam, which recorded the whole drive, showed he stayed in his lane. Babb’s patrol car had no forward-facing camera.

On his body camera, Babb said he worked in a Criminal Interdiction Unit, didn’t give tickets, and was looking for human and drug smuggling. Schott was patted down and questioned in the patrol car about his travel, family, home and record. When he refused a search, a dog unit was called. Court records allege the dog’s alert was prompted by its handler and unreliable, with roadkill nearby and the truck’s windows open.

Three deputies then spent about 40 minutes going through his truck, emptying bags and pulling at panels. They found nothing. Before letting him go, Babb said on camera that this is what happens “nine times out of ten.”

03

What the jury decided, and what it didn’t

The jury returned its verdict on September 28, 2026. It found Bexar County responsible at the level of policy or custom, which matters: the problem was treated as the county’s practice, not one deputy’s mistake. A traffic stop counts as a seizure, so police need an objective legal reason to start or extend one.

The verdict does not declare license plate readers unconstitutional. It says that in these circumstances, a surveillance alert about a travel route was not a lawful reason to stop and search this driver.

Schott says the trial showed his case wasn’t isolated. He said evidence showed deputies pulled over 20 or more cars daily and that 10 a day were searched without cause, and that his team showed 60 or 70 similar cases in less than three months. His lawyers at the Institute for Justice say the practice ran for about four years and affected thousands of drivers. Those are the plaintiff’s claims, not findings in the verdict.

Before suing, Schott had filed a complaint with the sheriff’s office. He says the department found no violation and told him he could sue if he disagreed. So he did.

Court documents and a gavel on a wooden table
04

What this means for drivers who pass plate reader cameras

Most drivers never think about plate readers, but the cameras are spreading. When Schott was stopped, only four Bexar County Sheriff’s Office vehicles carried plate readers. Today every patrol car in its fleet has one built into the dashcam.

The bigger concern is pattern-based flagging. An Associated Press investigation found that U.S. Border Patrol runs a program that watches drivers nationwide, flags vehicles by origin, destination and route, and refers them to local police, sometimes far from the border. At one stage, Flock Safety cameras alone gave the agency reach into 22 states and at least 1,600 cameras, the AP reported. Customs and Border Protection says its use of plate readers follows federal law and the Constitution.

Software can spot a correlation, like repeated drives toward a border region, but it can’t know why you went. A sales call, a family visit and a smuggling run can look identical on a map. Civil liberties groups also warn that some systems link cars that are often seen near each other, which could pull in a coworker or neighbor with no connection to any crime.

If you’re stopped and believe it’s based on a data tip rather than your driving, a few habits help:

  • A dashcam that records the road ahead can show whether a stated traffic reason holds up, as Schott’s did.
  • You can calmly decline consent to a search; officers then need another legal basis.
  • Write down names, times and what was said, and file a complaint if something seems wrong.
05

What happens next in Bexar County

The Institute for Justice plans to ask U.S. District Judge Orlando Garcia for a court order to stop similar unsupported stops and warrantless vehicle searches. How broad that order is will decide whether this case changes county practice or ends at $76. Bexar County has said it may appeal, and both the sheriff’s office and the district attorney’s office declined to comment, citing that possibility.

06

Quick answers

Why was the award only $76?

Schott asked for that exact amount as a symbol, one dollar for each minute he was detained. The point was the ruling, not the money.

Did the jury ban license plate readers?

No. It found that this stop, detention and search violated Schott’s rights and that the county was responsible. The cameras themselves remain legal.

Can police stop you just because of a plate reader alert?

They need an objective legal reason for any stop. In this case, the jury found a travel-pattern tip plus a disputed lane violation wasn’t enough.

You're reading the quick version.