Sunday, 22 November 2026

Apple Advanced Data Protection UK: still off despite court win

A tribunal has made the Home Office admit its secret order to Apple exists. The iCloud feature British users lost in 2025 stays off for now.

A smartphone resting beside a small padlock on a desk

The short version

  • A UK tribunal ruled on Thursday that the Home Office must confirm it served Apple with a secret data access order.
  • Advanced Data Protection stays unavailable in the UK because the ruling does not force the government to withdraw the order.
  • The first order reportedly reached iCloud users worldwide, and the current one is believed to cover UK users only.
  • A full hearing, much of it in public, is expected in the first half of 2027.
Quick read · 2 min

British iPhone owners still can't switch on Advanced Data Protection, Apple's optional setting that locks nearly everything in iCloud so that even Apple can't read it. Apple withdrew it for UK users in February 2025 after a secret government order sought access to encrypted data.

On Thursday a surveillance tribunal ruled that the Home Office must confirm the order exists. Three judges rejected the claim that admitting it would harm national security, noting the government's own briefings had already given the game away.

  • The order itself stays in force, so the feature is not returning yet.
  • The first version reportedly reached users worldwide; the current one is believed to cover UK users.
  • iMessage and FaceTime remain end-to-end encrypted in the UK.

Much of Apple's challenge can now be heard in public. The full hearing is expected in the first half of 2027, and a separate case brought by privacy groups has a hearing set for December.

Apple Advanced Data Protection in the UK is still switched off, and this week’s court win for Apple doesn’t bring it back. What has changed is that the British government can no longer act as if the reason for that doesn’t exist.

On Thursday, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal, an independent court that hears challenges to state surveillance, told the Home Office it has to confirm that it served Apple with a secret order seeking a way into encrypted iCloud data. If you use an iPhone in Britain, that order is the reason you can’t turn on Apple’s strongest cloud protection. It matters outside Britain too, because the first version of the demand reportedly reached customer data anywhere in the world.

01

Is Apple Advanced Data Protection in the UK coming back?

Not yet. The ruling stops the government from keeping the order’s existence a secret, but it doesn’t make ministers take the order back. So for now, people with Apple devices in Britain still can’t use the feature.

Apple withdrew Advanced Data Protection for UK users in February 2025. It blocked British customers from switching the feature on instead of doing what the order asked. The company gave no clear reason at the time, and the common reading was that this was a silent protest against a demand it wasn’t allowed to mention.

Whether the feature returns now depends on a legal fight that is only just moving into open court. The main hearing is expected in the first half of 2027.

A stone court building in London on a gray morning
02

What Advanced Data Protection does, and what UK users still have

Advanced Data Protection is an optional setting. It is not on by default. Once you enable it, end-to-end encryption covers almost everything you keep in iCloud, from Photos to device backups. End-to-end encryption means only you hold the keys, so even Apple can’t open the files.

Apple began offering it in 2022. Before then, the company already used end-to-end encryption for especially sensitive items such as health information and passwords.

Some protection is unchanged in Britain. iMessage and FaceTime are still end-to-end encrypted everywhere, the UK included.

03

What the tribunal ruled on Thursday

The three judges threw out the Home Office’s argument that admitting the order exists would harm national security. They described as “fanciful” the idea that an official acknowledgment would hand new information to a bad actor.

Their reasoning was blunt. The government has a policy of neither confirming nor denying orders like this one, but the tribunal found the government had already broken that policy itself. Two British newspapers had reported that government sources confirmed the order. The judges concluded those briefings did happen, and that special advisers, senior officials or ministers signed off on them.

The Home Office told the tribunal that its leak inquiries had found no source, yet it handed over no details of those inquiries. The government had also let Apple brief senior American officials, which the judges counted as one more break from its own rule. They even pointed out that anyone could get the answer by putting the question to Google’s chatbot.

Liberty, the rights group that brought a challenge on behalf of two individuals, says this is the first known case of the government being made to confirm that a secret technical order exists.

Server racks behind a locked cage door in a data center
04

What the secret order asks Apple to do

The order is called a technical capability notice, a power set out in the Investigatory Powers Act 2016. A notice like this can make a company change the way its service works so that the authorities can reach data, even when that data is encrypted. These notices come with strict non-disclosure rules, which is why Apple was legally barred from talking about this one even after details leaked.

The demand has changed shape since it first surfaced. The original order, reported last year, sought blanket access to encrypted iCloud backups belonging to users around the globe, not only those in Britain. That angered White House officials and US lawmakers, who argued it put Americans’ privacy at risk. After that clash with Washington, the Home Office dropped the worldwide demand.

A second, narrower notice followed. It is believed to focus on the data of British users, and Apple is fighting that one as well. The tribunal dismissed Apple’s first claim, and the company lodged a new one in July.

Narrower does not mean targeted. Reports on the newer notice say it would still require wide access to all encrypted material, and not just the contents of one named account.

The ruling doesn’t publish the order itself. The judges accepted that releasing all of the material would damage national security, while adding that this doesn’t mean each detail has to stay hidden. That question will be settled later.

05

What it means for iPhone users in the UK and beyond

For British users, nothing changes on your phone today. Advanced Data Protection stays unavailable, while iMessage and FaceTime keep their end-to-end encryption. What you gain is the right to watch: much of Apple’s case can now be argued in public, where before the government would not even admit there was anything to argue about.

For users outside the UK, the history is the part to know. The first order reportedly sought data from iCloud users anywhere in the world, and would have covered American customers as well as British ones. That worldwide demand has been withdrawn, and the current notice is believed to cover UK users’ data. One of the points the tribunal will hear in public is whether this power can reach interception outside the UK at all.

Apple’s own position hasn’t moved. Apple says it has never put a backdoor or a master key into anything it makes, and “never will”.

How Apple, the Home Office and privacy groups reacted

Apple said it welcomes the decision to make public the fact that the Home Office issued the notice.

The Home Office called the ruling procedural. In a statement, it said Apple has helped police and intelligence agencies for years, and that the notice simply requires the company to keep its ability to do that. A government spokesperson added that choices affecting public safety belong with elected governments and independent judges, not with technology company boardrooms.

Privacy groups see it very differently. Privacy International’s legal director called the ruling a “major victory”, and Liberty described it as a “victory for transparency”. Proton, a privacy tech company, welcomed the result but said the surveillance law behind the order is still dangerous, arguing that no encryption backdoor can be built to admit only well-meaning visitors.

06

What happens next in the Apple encryption case

The full hearing is expected in the first half of 2027, and the judges said much of it can take place in public. Apple is challenging the order on five grounds, and two of them can be settled fully in open court:

  • whether the power can be used to regulate the security a company offers its own customers;
  • whether the power can reach interception outside the UK.

The tribunal still has to decide which details of the order can be released. Privacy International and Liberty are also running a separate challenge, and both groups say they will keep contesting the government’s power to issue these orders in the first place. Privacy International says the substantive hearing in that case is scheduled for December of this year, which makes it the next date to watch.

07

Quick answers

Can I turn on Advanced Data Protection in the UK now?

No. The ruling only forces the government to confirm the order exists. It doesn’t reverse the order, so the feature remains unavailable to UK users for the immediate future.

Are iMessage and FaceTime still encrypted in the UK?

Yes. Apple’s communication services, including iMessage and FaceTime, remain end-to-end encrypted worldwide, and that includes the UK.

What is a technical capability notice?

It is an order under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 that can require a company to change how its service works so the authorities can get at data. The notices are issued under strict secrecy rules.

You're reading the quick version.