For most readers, the reviews point away from the Aluminum on value alone. One review named the $199.99 Paperwhite as its top pick among e-readers because of its smoother performance, waterproof build, warm lighting and larger 7-inch display.
The Aluminum makes sense for a narrower group: people who want the smallest Kindle, would pay to remove ads anyway, and care how the thing feels in the hand. One reviewer who said the upgrades do not justify the price also admitted she loves it.
If you already own a recent Kindle, the advice is blunter. Reviewers saw little reason to upgrade, and one pointed out that if color is the draw, a case does the same job for less.
Price history adds some sting. Before Amazon raised prices on its own devices in August, the base Kindle listed at $110, and sale prices sometimes dropped it to $80. The entry model now starts at $150, and the metal version pushes the small Kindle close to $200.