Friday, 20 November 2026

Olivia Moore maps where consumer AI companies actually make money

The a16z partner argues free, ad-supported AI could reach far more people than $20 subscriptions, as new spending data shows how few Americans pay.

ChatGPT, related to: Olivia Moore maps where consumer AI companies actually make money
Photo: Artem.G / CC BY 4.0 (modified)

The short version

  • Andreessen Horowitz released the seventh edition of its Top 100 consumer AI apps report on October 5, 2026.
  • As of August, only 4.5% of US consumers paid for a personal ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude subscription, up from 2.1% a year earlier.
  • Partner Olivia Moore says most people would rather get AI free with ads, and cheaper models could make that affordable.
  • She argues most consumer AI today is really prosumer AI, paid for by builders, marketers and other power users.
Quick read · 1 min

Andreessen Horowitz's latest Top 100 consumer AI apps report, published October 5, shows a market that is wide but shallow. Nearly half of Americans use AI, but only 4.5% pay for a personal ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude plan, and the top 10% of spenders make up about half of all spending.

Partner Olivia Moore says the answer is not forcing more people into subscriptions. She thinks most people would rather use AI free with ads, and that cheaper and open-source models can keep costs down. OpenAI's ChatGPT ads already hit a $1 billion run rate, while Anthropic refuses ads in Claude.

  • ChatGPT still leads, with Claude now a clear third.
  • Most paying users buy coding, creative and work tools.
  • Social, dating, travel, finance and health still lack big AI apps.

Expect more free, ad-backed AI apps and cheaper plans over the coming months.

Nearly half of Americans now say they use AI, yet only 4.5% pay for a personal ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude plan. That gap sits at the center of consumer AI economics, and Olivia Moore, a consumer AI partner at venture firm Andreessen Horowitz (a16z), thinks the fix is not more subscribers at all.

Her view matters if you use a chatbot every week without paying for it. The companies behind these tools are deciding how to earn money from free users like you, and the options on the table are ads, shopping fees and cheaper plans. Each one changes what you see and what it costs you.

01

What the a16z consumer AI report found

Moore’s comments came after a16z published the seventh edition of its Top 100 consumer AI apps list on October 5, 2026. The firm ranks the top 50 web products by monthly visits and the top 50 mobile apps by monthly users. For the first time, it also ranked companies by what Americans actually spend on their personal credit and debit cards, using panel data from YipitData.

ChatGPT still leads by a wide margin. It had roughly twice Gemini’s web visits in August and about six times Claude’s. Per the spending panel, ChatGPT also has three times as many paying US consumer subscribers as either rival. Claude has become the clear number three, and it passed Gemini on US consumer subscribers earlier this year.

Smaller specialists are holding on too. Moore pointed to music maker Suno and voice company ElevenLabs as apps with real staying power. Only 11 products appeared on the list for the first time, the fewest debuts across all seven editions.

People in a meeting room discussing AI apps and market trends
02

Why so few people pay for AI

The spending data shows how shallow paid use still is. As of August, 4.5% of US consumers had an active personal subscription to ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude, up from 2.1% a year earlier. A separate a16z market report put the share of US households paying for AI at barely more than two in a hundred.

The money is concentrated in very few hands. The top 10% of spenders account for about half of all observed consumer AI spending. The top 1% average about $903 a month on their personal cards, while the median paying user spends $25. Those heavy spenders mostly buy tools for coding, automation and creative work.

Moore told an interviewer that she isn’t sure she even wants the paying user number to rise. What interests her more is a world where people get value without pulling subscription money out of their own pockets. She said it is easy for high earners in Silicon Valley with company cards to prefer paying, but most people would rather use a tool free, see some ads, and then decide whether to pay to remove them.

03

Ads, cheaper models and the cost problem

Subscriptions bring in roughly 85% of the money earned by the web apps in the ranking, with ads making up only about 13 to 14%. Moore argues subscriptions have historically not scaled as well as ad-supported or transaction-based businesses. She estimated that if AI products matched the roughly $460 a year Google earns per user, US consumer AI could bring in up to $152 billion a year.

OpenAI is already testing this. Its ChatGPT ad business reached a $1 billion annualized run rate in August. Anthropic has taken the opposite path, saying it won’t run ads in Claude. Instead it sells hard to heavy users: 7.3% of Claude’s consumer payers are on its Max plan, which starts at $100 a month, compared with 1.3% at Google and 1.1% at ChatGPT on similar tiers.

The other hurdle is cost. Running an AI model for each request is much more expensive than serving a classic web page or search result. Moore said the industry is improving here, pointing to ChatGPT’s lower-priced Go plan, which she assumes runs on cheaper models. Not every task needs the most advanced AI, she said, so more consumer apps could run on lighter or open-source models (free models anyone can download and run).

A person using an AI app on a smartphone in a cafe
04

Consumer AI is mostly prosumer AI for now

Moore’s sharpest point is that much of what gets called consumer AI is really prosumer AI, meaning tools individuals buy for work. Before AI, consumer-first companies such as Canva often took six or seven years to add team plans. Now apps like Gamma, ElevenLabs and Cursor start with individual users and become mostly business-funded within about a year and a half.

On the spending list, she sees three groups doing the heavy lifting. Product-building apps such as Lovable, Replit and Fal let people make software. AI ad generators such as HeyGen and Higgsfield serve marketers. Work tools such as Granola, Manus and Fireflies AI handle notes and tasks. People often pay for these with personal cards at first, but they are not consumer apps in the old sense.

Europe has a strong showing in that money list. When the top 50 apps are ranked by what Americans spend each month, 11 come from Europe or were founded there, among them ElevenLabs, Synthesia, Photoroom and n8n.

05

What changes for everyday AI users

If Moore is right, the next wave of AI apps you try may be free and ad-supported rather than locked behind a $20 monthly fee. That could bring AI to people who will never pay for a subscription, but it also means more of your attention and data could become the product, as it did with social media and search.

Price tiers are likely to spread out too. Expect more low-cost plans that use cheaper models for everyday tasks, and premium plans for heavy users who need the most capable AI. If you pay today, check whether a cheaper tier covers what you actually do.

Moore also sees whole categories still waiting for AI. Her list had no entries in social, dating, marketplaces, retail, travel, finance or health, and she said that is where she wants to see new products over the next six months.

06

Quick answers

How many Americans pay for AI?

As of August 2026, 4.5% of US consumers had a paid personal subscription to ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude, up from 2.1% a year earlier.

Does ChatGPT show ads?

Yes. OpenAI says ChatGPT advertising reached a $1 billion annualized run rate in August. Anthropic says it won’t put ads in Claude.

Who is Olivia Moore?

She is a partner at Andreessen Horowitz who covers consumer AI and helps produce the firm’s Top 100 consumer AI apps report.

You're reading the quick version.