Only one in three US shoppers would let AI pick holiday deals
YouGov found planned AI use for Black Friday more than doubled in a year, yet almost nobody wants a bot to press buy. Newer surveys tell the same story.
A YouGov survey found 34% of US adults plan to use AI to navigate holiday sales, up from 16% a year earlier.
Shoppers mostly want AI for finding deals and comparing products; only 4% would let it buy something without asking.
Accuracy and sponsored results are the top worries, cited by 56% and 51% of AI shoppers.
Later surveys from Visa, Deloitte and Mall of America show the same gap between AI research and AI checkout.
Quick read · 1 min
A YouGov survey found 34% of US adults plan to use AI to help with Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales, more than double the 16% from a year earlier. Most people want AI only for research, though.
43% would use it to find the best deal
9% would let it add items to a cart
Just 4% would let it buy without asking
Trust is the barrier. More than half of AI shoppers worry about wrong or outdated information, and 51% fear sponsored results. Newer surveys agree: Deloitte found only 16% of consumers trust AI agents to complete purchases, and Visa's Trust Index puts trust in AI-handled payments at 23%.
If you use AI this season, keep it to finding and comparing deals, avoid sharing personal or payment details, and confirm every price on the retailer's own page before checking out.
About one in three American adults now plan to let AI help them hunt for Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals. But ask them to let a chatbot actually hit the buy button, and that number collapses to just 4%.
Those figures come from a YouGov survey of US adults, and they matter if you are deciding how much to trust AI shopping tools this season. Retailers and tech companies are racing to build AI agents that can find, compare and even buy products for you. Shoppers, it turns out, are happy to use the research help and very wary of everything after that.
01
How many people will use AI for holiday shopping
YouGov found that 34% of US adults plan to use AI to help navigate holiday sales this year, more than double the 16% who said so a year earlier. That still means fewer than half of Black Friday and Cyber Monday shoppers expect to touch AI at all.
Habits stick once people try it. Last year, 21% of holiday shoppers used AI during sales, and 92% of that group plan to use it the same amount or more this year. Only 8% plan to cut back.
The holdouts are a big bloc, though. Some 47% of holiday shoppers didn’t use AI last year and don’t plan to start, compared with 22% who will try it for the first time. Across all US adults, 40% say they won’t even consider using AI for holiday shopping.
The US also trails other countries. Only 18% of American adults have used AI tools to shop, against half of adults in India and 54% in Saudi Arabia. Another 21% of Americans say they would consider it. Black Friday shoppers are keener, with 30% having already tried AI shopping and 27% open to it.
02
What shoppers will and won’t let AI do
Shoppers are comfortable letting AI do the legwork but not the spending. The closer a task gets to checkout, the fewer people want a bot involved. Among Black Friday shoppers, YouGov found:
43% would use AI to find the best deal
34% would use it to compare similar products or offers
37% would use it to track price changes
9% would let it add items to their cart
5% would let it complete a purchase they had approved
4% would let it buy something without asking first
That drop-off is the whole story. People see AI as a smarter search engine, not a personal shopper with their credit card.
03
Why trust is the sticking point
The top worry is plain accuracy: 56% of AI shoppers are concerned the tools could give them wrong or outdated information, such as an expired deal or an old price. Close behind, 51% fear biased or sponsored recommendations.
That second fear is worth taking seriously. If an AI assistant’s results can be shaped by what advertisers want rather than what is cheapest or best, shoppers could be steered without knowing it. Most AI tools don’t make it obvious how they rank products, so it’s hard to tell a genuine bargain from a paid placement.
Newer research points the same way. A Deloitte survey of 4,000 US consumers in August and September found only 16% trust AI agents to complete purchases for them, while 66% worry about how AI assistants use their data. Still, 37% said they feel more comfortable with agents than they did six months earlier.
04
What newer holiday surveys say
Other polls published since the YouGov results show AI creeping into shopping routines while checkout stays in human hands.
Visa’s holiday survey of 1,016 US adults, run by Morning Consult in late September and early October, found 54% have turned to AI for some part of their shopping, compared with 47% a year ago. The favorite jobs are practical ones: finding discounts (57%), comparing prices (61%), suggesting gifts (54%) and checking stock (59%). Yet only 23% of US consumers trust generative AI to handle a payment for them, based on Visa’s separate Trust Index. Gen Z is the most enthusiastic group, with 73% willing to let AI suggest gift ideas.
The survey also found 41% of Americans would not admit that AI helped pick a gift.
A Mall of America poll of 1,775 consumers found 45% expect to use AI for at least one holiday task, most often comparing products or prices (22%) and finding promotions (18%). But fewer than 1% picked AI as their first source of gift ideas. Half said friends and family come first, and 28% said browsing in stores. A Gartner survey from August found 34% of US consumers very or extremely willing to use AI chatbots for gift recommendations, so interest in AI gift ideas depends a lot on how the question is asked.
AI can save you time this season, as long as you keep it on the research side of the counter. Use it to narrow a long list of options, surface gifts you hadn’t thought of, and spot when a price drops. Then check the details yourself before you pay.
A few practical rules help:
Share less. You can ask for gift ideas for a kid who loves soccer without giving their age, name or your address.
Keep payment details out of chatbots. Your card, shipping address and account logins are worth a lot to scammers if they leak.
Verify every price and deal. Open the retailer’s own page and confirm the price, stock and return terms before you buy.
Watch for sponsored picks. If the same brand keeps topping every answer, compare it against a normal search.
Fraud is a real risk this time of year. Visa found nearly three in 10 shoppers were targeted by fraud during last year’s holiday season, rising to 39% among Gen Z. Turning on two-factor sign-in and not saving cards on unfamiliar sites are simple defenses.
06
Quick answers
How many Americans will use AI for holiday shopping?
YouGov puts it at 34% of US adults planning to use AI for holiday sales, up from 16% a year earlier. Visa puts the share who have used AI for some shopping job at 54%.
Will AI buy things for me automatically?
Some tools can, but very few people want that. Only 4% of Black Friday shoppers would let AI buy without asking, and 5% would let it finish a purchase they approved.
Is it safe to use AI for Black Friday deals?
It is reasonably safe for research if you avoid sharing personal or payment details and double-check prices on the store’s own site before buying.
Google Play will block new apps and updates that letterbox or lose your place on foldables, and store listings will soon show the unfolded screen first.
Apple says a change it pushed itself, not hackers, broke iCloud sign-ins, Apple Pay and the App Store for hours on Tuesday. Here's what failed and why.
6 min read
We use cookies to understand how readers use Talk With Tech, so we can make it better. Is that OK? Privacy policy
The Daily Brief
Today's biggest tech stories, in 5 minutes
Every morning, the news that matters from AI, phones, apps and the people shaping tech. Explained in plain English. Free.
One email a day. No spam, unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy