As recently as October 5, both labs wanted firm editorial control over what reviewers could publish, the two sources said. By October 8, Anthropic’s talks with some evaluators seemed to have shifted.
Anthropic said that description did not cover all of its work. Evaluators it has worked with before, it said, control their own methods, criteria, conclusions and what they publish. For firms that are new to it, though, Anthropic reserves the right to review and approve reports during an early getting-to-know-you phase.
OpenAI, for its part, denied wanting approval over entire reports. Its usual practice is to black out confidential details, and evaluators are free to say publicly when big redactions were made.
One contract Reuters saw showed how far standard terms can reach: its wording can stop review firms from publishing confidential company information without the lab’s consent. That is common across the tech industry, but critics argue AI carries much higher stakes.