The biggest difference between these earbuds is how they sit in your ear, and everything else follows from it. AirPods 5 are solid, slightly oval buds with no tips. You pop them in with a gentle twist and they rest in the outer ear without plugging it. That is what people mean by an open-ear design.
AirPods Pro 3 work the other way. They come with replaceable silicone tips, infused with foam, in five sizes, and the tip seals your ear canal. That seal blocks sound physically before any electronics get involved, and it also helps music sound fuller.
Both pairs have Active Noise Cancellation, the feature that uses microphones to cancel out steady sounds like engines and air conditioning. On the AirPods 5, it leans on a new internal design Apple calls a multiport acoustic architecture. But Apple itself says the Pro 3 provide up to three times as much noise cancellation as the AirPods 5, because of that physical seal. One reviewer who has used both called the difference easy to notice in testing. Other reviewers found the real-world gap smaller than Apple’s figure implies, and praised how much the AirPods 5 block for the money.
Sound is not identical either. In one hands-on comparison, the AirPods 5 came across as muddier than the Pro 3, mostly in the lower midrange.
Comfort is personal, though. Some people find tips in the ear canal unpleasant after an hour. Others find open buds work loose, and reviewers say the AirPods 5 can feel less secure during workouts. If you already know which camp you are in, much of this decision is made.